Behind the Artifact: Mother Seton’s Calvary Piece or the Filicchi Wood Carving - Seton Shrine

Behind the Artifact: Mother Seton’s Calvary Piece or the Filicchi Wood Carving

The National Shrine of Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton will highlight an exhibit in its new museum and its significance in the life of the first person born in America to become a saint.

The Details

For at least 207 years, a large wood carving featuring the scene from Calvary hung on the wall of the White House that was home to Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton and St. Joseph’s Academy, the Catholic school for girls that she founded. The carving  was recently moved to the Servant Gallery of the National Shrine of Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton’s new $4 million museum that will open on Sept. 22.

The piece is quite large measuring 64”H x 35” W. It is constructed of carved and joined wood. The surfaces are prepared with a white gesso and decorated with paint and gilded bead moldings. The carving has been repainted and conserved on several occasions. The original colors were most likely much brighter.

It is possible that the floral cartouche atop the canopy and the base were added on later.

The History

The origins of the carving are unclear, since there is nothing in Mother Seton’s writing that says when she received the piece or was even in the White House during her time. But there is some supporting evidence that it was a gift from the Filicchi family, who played a key role in her conversion to Catholicism.

The Daughters of Charity list it as a gift from the Filicchis, and most likely came from Gubbio, Italy. There is evidence that the Filicchi not only gave Elizabeth financial support but also gifted her with many beautiful objects as well. There is, for example, a bill of sale of $53 for nine vases that were sent to Elizabeth from Livorno, most likely from the Filicchis in 1818.

The most valuable evidence that the woodcarving was hanging above the fireplace in the sitting room, the room that Mother Seton died in, is a sketch done by Fr. Simon Brute in 1816.

Courtesy of Daughters of Charity, Province of St. Louise, Provincial Archives, Emmitsburg, Maryland.












This sketch shows Elizabeth kneeling at the bedside of her daughter, Rebecca. Rebecca died on November 3, 1816, having just reached the age of fourteen. Clearly, the woodcarving is above the fireplace without the extra embellishments. The Daughters currently have over eighty of Brute’s sketches in their collection. These sketches have become important as they speak to the history of what was happening at the school and the Sisterhood that Mother Seton founded during her time.

The Filicchis

Antonio and Filippo Filicchi were wealthy business associates of Elizabeth’s husband William, and they would take care of her and her children after his death.

“In addition to the orders left with you on my departure from America,” wrote Antonio Filicchi to John Murray and Sons, his New York agents, in 1806, “you are requested to furnish Mrs. Seton with whatever further sum she might at any time call for, to support herself and family.” (The Filicchi Brothers and St. Elizabeth Ann Seton page 105)

Filippo Filicchi is said to have spent several years in the United States, at which time he became familiar to George Washington who later made him the American consul in Leghorn, Italy. Filicchi was ap­pointed consul on 10 December 1794, assumed charge at Leghorn on 20 March 1795, and retired from office in November 1798.

Filippo and his brother, Antonio were merchants and formed the F & A Filicchi Company, which did business with Seton, Maitland & Co., a shipping company started by Elizabeth’s father-in-law, William Seton. The Filicchis were part of the bankruptcy of the Seton company. The two brothers had filed a complaint with the New York City authorities in order to recover the $5,614.73 due to their company due to mismanagement of record books on the part of Seton, Maitland & Company.  This equates to $140,686.26 today.

The debt did not stand in the way of friendship. The brothers had known Elizabeth’s husband, William Magee, from an early age. He had gone to Italy to do an internship at the Filicchi firm and made several trips to visit and to do business before his marriage to Elizabeth.

In 1803 when William was showing signs of tuberculosis, he took Elizabeth and their daughter, Anna Maria, to Leghorn to stay with the Filicchis. The Filicchis provided for them when they were in the lazaretto and helped Elizabeth after William died. They would be the catalyst that would change her life and the lives of so many to come as they introduced her to the Catholic faith.

For more information about the new museum and visitor center at the National Shrine of Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton, visit here.